Author Topic: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?  (Read 39566 times)

thaimonk

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 652
Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« on: July 22, 2010, 10:20:38 AM »
Is Geshe Kelsang Gyatso a Geshe? I am not saying he is not, or think negatively of him, I am just wondering where this comes from? It is apparently written by a close student? The statement below published by NKT secretary 1998:

http://www.nktworld.org/gyatsocred.html


The below statement does not make Geshe Kelsang unqualified to teach or hold lineages, but it is undermining and reavealing regarding his student's stances.

1. Is he a Geshe?
2. Has he recieved forwards for his earlier books from Dalai Lama?b Which book(s)? Does anyone know?
3. If he has, does he used Dalai Lama's reference to him as Geshe to be the basis of a Geshe doctrate holder?
4. If the Dalai Lama is a liar as purported by some NKT members/Geshe-la, then did the Dalai Lama lie when he referred to Geshe-la as a Geshe in his forward?
5. Geshe Kelsang and Dalai Lama had this fall out ONLY BECAUSE OF THE SHUGDEN issue? So Geshe-la has all pictures of Dalai Lama removed from NKT because he doesn't agree with Dalai Lama? So should all pictures/drawings of Trijang Rinpoche be removed from NKT because Trijang Rinpoche believed in the tulku/oracle institution?
6. Did Geshe-la and Lama Yeshe have a fall out? Lama Yeshe was not a Geshe doctrate holder also I heard. Neither is Lama Zopa (his student), but they both have organizations well known throughout the world. If Geshe-la had a fall out with Lama Yeshe decades ago and with Dalai Lama, aren't we taught to have patience and forgive?


These are questions that arise in my mind when I came across the below article. Can anyone clarify the points? Just the points please?



=================================================================================================


GYATSO CREDENTIALS

NKT's support for Gyatso's purported Geshe degree is quoted below. However, there is no evidence of an actual document (degree) such as those granted by academic institutions. To NKT, since Gyatso seemed like he received a degree, he did.

'Geshe' is an academic-like degree granted by a monastery, not a university. While Gyatso was a Buddhist monk in the Gelug tradition during his training (never completed) to earn the Geshe degree, he has since separated from Tibetan Buddhism. Thus, in effect, by creating an indepedant 'religion' Gyatso ordained himself and granted himself a Geshe degree.

(Gyatso is not a Lama, which is a title of respect for a Tibetan teacher of Buddhism, eg The Dalai Lama, Lama Yeshe, Lama Zopa and Lama Namkhai Norbu Rinpoche - all subject to abuse by Gyatso and his NKT corporation on NKT web sites and in NKT protest rallies.)

Letters to and about Gyatso from Sera Monastery (August 1996) offically expelling Gyatso are instructive and unequivocal, and other comments from Tibet are appropos...

From Sera Je,

"His Holiness The Dalai Lama is the undisputed leader of the six million Tibetans and a world renowned Buddhist leader as well as a respected statesman of great charisma for which he was awarded the prestigious 1989 Nobel Peace Prize among many others. His genuine concern for the welfare of the Tibetan people, the weak and the down trodden and his teachings on compassion to bring about a more humane and harmonious world and his call for the protection of all forms of life on our planet and their habitat in the form of what he termed as ‘Universal Responsibility’ has caught the imagination of the world and is held in great esteem by virtually the whole world irrespective of their religious affiliations or political ideology.

However, it is a measure of profound sorrow that a so called “Geshe” Kelsang Gyatso and his English supporters have embarked upon a ruthless smear campaign to tarnish the International stature of His Holiness The Dalai Lama in the name of alleged “religious persecution”. It is nothing short of blasphemy in the eyes of the overwhelming majority of the six million Tibetans.

It is nothing but a crude form of debasing the Dalai Lama for his own selfish ends...We have nothing but pity for your ignorance...Why not mind his own business and do what he likes in his own bigoted kingdom?

Actions speak louder than words and we are under no illusion with whom your sympathies are despite your statements to the contrary. The Tibetans all over the world were deeply distressed by your attempt to portray the Dalai Lama as a “ruthless dictator” an “oppressor of his own people” and smash his International stature so that the Tibetan struggle will be like a rudderless ship tossing helplessly in the sea of international intrigues and treacery. From where did you borrow your vocabulary to malign the Dalai Lama? Are they not straight from the Chinese propaganda dictionary?

These days, [in Kelsang Gyatso] the demonic cloud of overwhelming arrogance displays itself with a mass of deluded pride, like a bat who thinks he is above the sky…. This demon with broken commitments…. burns with the flame of unbearable spite towards the unsurpassed omniscient 14th Dalai Lama, the only staff of life of religious people in Tibet, whose activities and kindness are equal to the sky.

...Kelsang Gyatso who is today a pariah in the Tibetan community...

We advise him to accept the fact that he is an ordinary being and stand no chance whatsoever to challenge the Dalai Lama. He is not even a Geshe. The so called “third Buddha” is a figment of imagination conjured up by his fawning desciples as a propaganda tool to attract more people to his centre and that it should not go to his head.

Kelsang himself has transgressed the eight shortcomings of relying wrongly upon his own spiritual master H.H. The Dalai Lama. According to the circular released by the Sera Jhe Tsangpa Khangtsen, to whom Kelsang belonged, he had received both sutra and tantric teachings from H.H. The Dalai Lama when he was in Tibet. He had received the fifth Dalai Lama’s Lamrim Jampel Shalung at the Norbu Linka summer palace and the Kalachakra Initiation in 1956 from H.H.The Dalai Lama which incidently was the first Kalachakra initiation by the fourteenth Dalai Lama. As it were, there is simply no question of his not being a desciple of H.H. The Dalai Lama but he has ignored this aspect and launched a blistering attack on the Dalai Lama in the name of “religious persecution” along with his gullible followers. The outcome of all this attempt to denigrate the person of the of Dalai Lama by Kelsang clearly transgressed his spiritual relationship with the Dalai Lama and though he has mentioned in his letter that “all of us are destined to go to hell”, we are in no doubt that he will infact be the one who will land in hell.

We have therefore stripped him of his membership from our Sera Jhe Dratsang since the holy scriptures have clearly prescribed to evict such apostates who will foul the Sanga community’s spiritual purity and serenity and will have a negative influence for the whole community. Owing to the above reasons contained in the holy Tantric treatises, the Sera Jhe Dratsang’s Abbot and ex-abbots, Reincarnations of holy Lamas, Geshes, and the House Masters of the fifteen different Houses unanimously decided to strip Kelsang Gyatso of his membership in the Sera Jhe Dratsang and his own House had earlier done the same.

He states that for the last eighteen years the Dalai Lama has done nothing!!! His hatred towards the Dalai Lama obscures him from seeing any merit of the Dalai Lama...It is not the fault of the holy Buddha, nor Lama Tsongkhapa nor H.H.The Dalai Lama but the beholder like Kelsang Gyatso whose demonic instinct get the better of them...He is an object of pity and nothing else.

We sincerely hope that the cult leader and his fanatical supporters go through this and think twice before their vitriolic outpourings on the holy person of the Dalai Lama. We believe you would trust the Chinese version more than ours and because of this we took the liberty to quote from the Chinese communist periodical. It would be even better if you would care to go through the whole article and you will be surprised that even the Chinese communists have far greater respect for the Dalai Lama than cult leader Kelsang Gyatso and his cultists in Cumbria, England!!! What’s more, if any one disagrees with his “pure” cult, he gets the boot...But with Kalsang anything goes, after all he is the “third buddha” in the British Isles.


His venomous invectives against the Dalai Lama is unbecoming of a Buddhist...


The sacrilege he was committing by banning the photos of the Dalai Lama and even the utterance of his name in the premises of his cult kingdom. It is an unheard piece of news which every Tibetan will condemn with the severest indiction. The motivation behind this act was, he was now planning to wean away innocent, unsuspecting, young minds towards his cultist school called the “New Kadampa Tradition” which imposes a ban on Tibet’s Spiritual and Temporal leader the Dalai Lama and thus undermine his authority even in the exile community. His single minded motivation now is to undermine the authority of the Dalai Lama and maroon the Tibetan people. This is unacceptable to the six million Tibetans and we will challenge him for this.

In his apparent ecstasy, he even disowns being a Tibetan and works against the very people where he was born.

His Holiness Tenzin Gyatso, the 14th Dalai Lama, is the embodiment of the compassion of all Buddhas, the golden flower in the land of snows, Tibet, the form of the deity who has appeared in Tibet, the representative of Buddha Shakyamuni, the spiritual leader of all Buddhists in the world, and the great advocate of non-violence.

For those who come from the land of snow mountains, to find in His Holiness our sacred source of refuge for this and future lives is truly our inborn nature, like our eyes which give us sight and our innermost heart.

(referring to Gyatso)...Possessed by a terrible demon, without shame, embarrassment, or modesty, he doesn't have even the slightest care or concern for any of the commitments of the three vows [pratimoksha, bodhicitta, and tantric] which he undertook.

He continuously broadcasts blatantly shameless mad pronouncements, attacking with baseless slander His Holiness the Dalai Lama, whose kindness for us, the people of Tibet, has been greater that the Buddhas of the three times. These unimaginable statements which defame the name of His Holiness have created an urgent adverse situation which no Tibetan can tolerate.

Therefore, all those connected with Sera Je College, lamas and tulkus, abbots, former executives, senior and junior geshes, together with the leaders of the individual khangtsen [regional houses], all together, in agreement, with one voice, hereby proclaim that on this day, August 22, 1996, Kelsang Gyatso, the one with broken commitments and wrong view, is cast out with the "ritual nine expulsions," and is thereby banished from this place, and the being a part of the rule of our College.

This means that we request all of our brothers and sisters, the Tibetan people inside and outside Tibet, to completely sever any relationship with him. Concerning the practice of worshiping divine protectors at this Monastery in particular, the protector who was directed by the previous great masters to advise, command, and look after our Monastery is the Dharma protector Dregpa Chamsing [Dregs Pa lCam Sring). Aside from this protector there has traditionally been no worship of Dolgyal [Dorje Shugden].

These days, we keep in the honored position on the crown of our heads the instructions of our Government, the great Ganden Potrang. Therefore, all sangha who reside here, as evidence of their commitment not to worship the protector Dolgyal, have freely signed such a pledge, and offered it before the clear eye of His Holiness. Beyond that, anyone who is not blind should be able to comprehend this with their ordinary eye of understanding and mind of attachment and aversion; as they say, no one needs a lamp to make things clear in the light of the sun and moon.

For the future, we publicly make the strongest request to everyone not to associate the good name of Sera Je Monastery with this holder of broken commitments and wrong view."

Representatives of the Tibetan people echoed these sentiments about Gyatso's fall from the Buddhist path.

For example, from the Freedom Movement, Youth Congress, Tibetan Women's Association and representatives of the Three Provinces Movement,

"… you are doomed life after life… telling others not to keep pictures of the Dalai Lama reveals that, although you wear the mask of a religious practitioner, in reality you are the running dog of China and Taiwan. Therefore, we the Tibetan people both inside and outside Tibet will unitedly stand against you as a source of harm to the spiritual and temporal affairs of Tibetans."

From Tibetans in Dharamsala to 'All the followers of Geshe Kelsang Gyatso',

"It is also a well-known fact that due to a slight disagreement on views with His Holiness the Dalai Lama, you had banned portraits of His Holiness in your business-oriented Dharma centers. This insane and demeanous (sic) act had caused disgrace to the Tibetans as a whole and is no better than the savageous acts of the Red Chinese. We, the six million Tibetans, solemnly denounce these ill-acts."

From Tibetan Community, Kathmandu, Nepal,

"We feel called upon ourselves to let you know of certain facts about him so that his impudent ravings do not lead astray well-meaning followers of the path….Your "guru" has the misguided audacity to challenge the omniscience of the Compassionate One to the utter disgust of us all."

In a 1996 response to Gyatso's letter referred to above, a Tibetan wrote,

"I suspect that this may have been instigated by the Chinese communists as his accusations of H.H. the Dalai Lama are so baseless, convoluted and depraved...Kalzang Gyatso praises the spirit, Dolgyal, with such exaggeration, trying to make him the powerful guardian of the Gelugpa doctrine, with such falsification that there is no truth whatsoever. He has caused a schism by claiming that His Holiness restricts and suppresses the Gelugpa doctrine...If one is blind, everything that appears in front is only darkness...it is the responsibility of all knowledgeable lay and ordained individuals of the snow-land of Tibet to strongly refute, with the three methods of reason, scripture and instruction, the one that hurts Buddhism in general and the Gelugpa school in particular with his evil conduct and distorted views. Having distinguished between bragrant flowers and poisonous grass, we should defeat this propounder of perversity."

'All lies' according to Gyatso and his sycophantic foot soldiers.

(In 2008, Gyatso's attacks on The Dalai Lama and other esteemed Tibetan Lamas intensified with web sites, web blogs, intimidation of NKT's critics and media-saavy protests.)

Two years after Gyatso's letters from Sera Monastery, Gyatso's attempted to defend his purported Geshe degree (published by NKT's Secretary in 1998).

“In Tibet before he joined Sera-je Monastery near Lhasa, Geshe Kelsang studied on the Geshe training program for many years in his local monastery of Jampaling. He then took two examinations at the great monastic university of Tashi Lhunpo, one for memorization of texts, the second being the actual examination. After the second examination he was awarded a degree from that monastery, and from that time on the other monks and local people called him Geshe Kelsang.

Later, he continued with the Geshe training programme in Sera-je Monastery until he left for India in 1959, where he alternately studied and engaged in meditation retreats. One day he received a letter from Sera-je Monastery in south India, encouraging him to attend a Geshe offering ceremony and to take an examination in order to receive a certificate. In 1973 he went to Sera Monastery and made an extensive offering at the Geshe offering ceremony to a large assembly of monks from both Sera-je and Sera-mey monasteries, in Sera Tsogchen Prayer Hall. He also made the traditional offerings to Sera-je Monastery. On that occasion the monks of his class offered him a ‘katag’, or ceremonial scarf, and gifts in the traditional way. If he was not considered a Geshe then what was the point of inviting him to participate in this ceremony?

At that time he declined to take the examination, which was a new system that had been recently introduced. He later explained that this was because he did not think that receiving a piece of paper was important."

With such delusional logic we could all grant ourselves doctorates.

 

 
Editor's Note:
Gyatso insists that the many reports that he is a fake Geshe are lies (Gyatso uses the 'lie' charge often against the Dalai Lama, other Tibetan Lamas, other Buddhists and the media):

“My true situation is that in Tibet I studied Geshe training for many years in my local monastery called Jampa Ling and Tashi Lhunpo university and I passed two examinations. One examination was in memorization and the other was the actual examination. Soon after that, people would publicly call me “Geshe”.

Later in Tibet I joined Sera Je monastery and I studied Geshe training further. In India I mainly emphasized retreat for meditation purposes. When I was living on a high mountain called Dalhousie I received a letter from Sera Je monastery. The letter encouraged me to go to Sera for an examination. Because I had heard that the method or system for examinations was newly created, I did not accept this new system.

However, in 1973 I did my Geshe Ceremony in Sera Je monastery, making extensive offerings to thousands of monks; and I received a special traditional khatag (white scarf) indicating that I am a Geshe.

Generally for anyone to become a real Geshe it is not necessary that the Dalai Lamas recognize them as a Geshe. Before the Dalai Lamas, so many pure and real Geshes appeared such as Geshe Potowa, Geshe Jayulwa, Geshe Langri Tangpa, Geshe Sharawa, Geshe Chekawa and so forth. These Kadampa Geshes have no connection with the Dalai Lama. I have no connection with the Dalai Lama but I still believe that I am a Geshe.

Please give a copy of this information to people if they request it. Thank you.”

On one point, Gyatso may be correct. Before the Dalai Lamas (the first Dalai Lama was a student of Tsongkhapa (1357-1419); the current Dalai Lama is the 14th), there were Geshes without recognition by a Dalai Lama. Because Gyatso despises the six hundred year lineage of Dalai Lamas, he bases his (fake) Geshe degree on pre-Dalai Lama history.

The Geshe degree is a academic-like degree, analogous to a doctorate in Buddhist theology.

Apparently, Gyatso has never been awarded the degree per se, e.g., he holds no diploma. The basis for his Geshe title is that he believes that he is a Geshe. Hopefully, he doesn't start believing that he can fly or is the President or Prime Minister. Gyatso's reliance on the Dalai Lama is notable.

Normally, Gyatso claims that the Dalai Lama is an evil liar. In this instance, Gyatso says that the Geshe degree is not based on recognition by the Dalai Lama but since the Dalai Lama called him a Geshe in a book forward that this is support for Gyatso holding the Geshe degree
.

Interestingly, one of Gyatso's books was dedicated to the Dalai Lama in its first printing but in later printings, this dedication was removed. Obviously, when Gyatso likes what you are saying he will use it, when he doesn't he will call you a liar (this is the tactic widely used by NKT Internet bloggers as well).

Once again, readers should decide for themselves the credibility of Gyatso and NKT.

As for a friend of ours we call 'Doc', we pray he does not try performing surguries on patients, or a friend we call 'Captain', we pray he does not take control of an oil tanker or an airliner.

(Gyatso refers to Geshe Kelsang Gyatso)
 

« Last Edit: July 22, 2010, 12:44:09 PM by thaimonk »


lightning

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 314
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #2 on: July 23, 2010, 11:04:39 PM »
Potowa is reconginsed as a Geshe although he was not conferred with Lharmpa Degree. Mastery of Dharma understanding cannot be measured by any degree or certificate. There are prodigy who graduated from doctorate at early age. There are lineage masters who got instant enlightenment upon thrown with torma. These lamas have been practicing in previous lives to manifest in unusual speed in understanding or learning. Maybe it is best that one should have an interview to find out more.

LosangKhyentse

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 850
  • WORLD PEACE PROTECTOR DORJE SHUGDEN
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #3 on: July 23, 2010, 11:08:37 PM »
Potowa is reconginsed as a Geshe although he was not conferred with Lharmpa Degree. Mastery of Dharma understanding cannot be measured by any degree or certificate. There are prodigy who graduated from doctorate at early age. There are lineage masters who got instant enlightenment upon thrown with torma. These lamas have been practicing in previous lives to manifest in unusual speed in understanding or learning. Maybe it is best that one should have an interview to find out more.

I agree with you and have no debate. What you wrote and the examples you give are for people who have knowledge of Dharma, Potawa, etc. For those who don't, it would help to explain and research more.

I don't have any doubts with Ven. Geshe Kelsang at all. I admire him very much in fact.

tk

lightning

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 314
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #4 on: July 24, 2010, 01:17:52 PM »
Potowa is reconginsed as a Geshe although he was not conferred with Lharmpa Degree. Mastery of Dharma understanding cannot be measured by any degree or certificate. There are prodigy who graduated from doctorate at early age. There are lineage masters who got instant enlightenment upon thrown with torma. These lamas have been practicing in previous lives to manifest in unusual speed in understanding or learning. Maybe it is best that one should have an interview to find out more.

I agree with you and have no debate. What you wrote and the examples you give are for people who have knowledge of Dharma, Potawa, etc. For those who don't, it would help to explain and research more.

I don't have any doubts with Ven. Geshe Kelsang at all. I admire him very much in fact.

tk
i second to that as I have been enjoying reading up His books before I met my Lama.

vinayafan

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 3
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #5 on: July 24, 2010, 02:35:50 PM »
A degree is an achievement for practitioners along the path. However it is not a measure of one's enlightened state of mind.
There are so many masters acclaimed as realized or enlightened without degrees.China's famous 6th Patriarch Hui Neng was an illiterate.
Who cares, as long as what they write benefit people , consistent with Dharma and had withstood the test of time.
I am sure many respectable institution of learning will be happy to award Geshe-la a degree on the strength of the many wonderful dharma books he had published which had transformed many people's lives for the better. I don't think people's respect for him is dependent on whether he has a title or not although it is interesting to know the history for the sake of getting the records right.

Yeshe

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 50
    • Email
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #6 on: July 24, 2010, 06:06:03 PM »
I have met a number of Geshes,  Lharampa Geshes included.

The qualification is no guarantee of ability to teach, nor even of fitness as a spiritual guide.

There are many Lamas who are not ordained.  How is it logical to say that GKG is not a Lama becuase he is not a Geshe?

Neither does a Tantric Master need to be ordained as a monk, and GKG received transmission form the same great masters as HHDL.  He may have received empowerments from HHDL simply by being a participant in a mass ritual, like tens of thousands of others.

In practical terms, therefore, GKG would gain no useful advantage from his Geshe status, so why would he lie?

Buddhism survived pretty well long before the Geshe programme was started, and other Tibetan schools do not seem to regard it as essential.

There was even a guy called Shakyamuni who was not a Geshe either.

In short, why focus on that issue at all ?

Maybe it is a sad and illogical attempt to disqualify and discredit him as a great spiritual leader.

The West has many Geshes.  It may be prudent to ask if the remarkable growth and significance of the NKT points not only to the good qualities of the teacher, but also those of his Protector, Dorje Shugden.

A compassionate mind cannot be penetrated by anger or attachment.

Dharmapal

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 67
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #7 on: July 24, 2010, 06:12:12 PM »
Geshe Kelsang is a Geshe.

In the colophon to Geshe Kelsang's long life prayer written by Kyabje Trijang Rinpoche himself (available from Tharpa Publications free of charge), it says:

"This brief prayer for the long life of the Tsang-pa Geshe, Kelsang Gyatso, of Sera-Je Monastery, who is endowed with great learning and immaculate pure conduct, was composed by Yongdzin Trijang Dorjechang at the request of the community at Manjushri Centre, England."

In the foreword to Geshe Kelsang’s book Meaningful to Behold, Venerable Trijang Rinpoche says:

The excellent expounder, the great Spiritual Master Kelsang Gyatso, who studied myriad Buddhist scriptures at the famous Je College of the great monastic university of Sera Tegchen Ling, practised the meaning of the teachings he received, and became a wise, serious and realized Teacher.

Geshe Kelsang says:

“My true situation is that in Tibet I studied Geshe training for many years in my local monastery called Jampa Ling and Tashi Lhunpo university and I passed two examinations. One examination was in memorization and the other was the actual examination. Soon after that, people would publicly call me “Geshe”.

Later in Tibet I joined Sera Je monastery and I studied Geshe training further. In India I mainly emphasized retreat for meditation purposes. When I was living on a high mountain called Dalhousie I received a letter from Sera Je monastery. The letter encouraged me to go to Sera for an examination. Because I had heard that the method or system for examinations was newly created, I did not accept this new system.

However, in 1973 I did my Geshe Ceremony in Sera Je monastery, making extensive offerings to thousands of monks; and I received a special traditional khatag (white scarf) indicating that I am a Geshe.

Generally for anyone to become a real Geshe it is not necessary that the Dalai Lamas recognize them as a Geshe. Before the Dalai Lamas, so many pure and real Geshes appeared such as Geshe Potowa, Geshe Jayulwa, Geshe Langri Tangpa, Geshe Sharawa, Geshe Chekawa and so forth. These Kadampa Geshes have no connection with the Dalai Lama. I have no connection with the Dalai Lama but I still believe that I am a Geshe.

Please give a copy of this information to people if they request it. Thank you.”

Geshe Kelsang's qualities are extolled in the prefaces of some of his books by high Lamas, including Venerable Yongdzin Ling Rinpoche and Trijang Rinpoche, who were the lineage holders of the Gelugpa tradition.

In the foreword to Geshe Kelsang's book, Clear Light of Bliss, Yongdzin Ling Rinpoche says:

This excellent commentary on the joyous Mahamudra
Derived from churning the essence of the ocean of Tantric scriptures
That arose from the heart of this most precious Spiritual Guide
Is published with a pure wish to benefit migrators.

In the prayer he composed "for the long life of the Venerable Geshe Kelsang Gyatso", Trijang Rinpoche says:

You who are skilled in the wisdom that unties the sealed knots
Of the profound meaning of the Sutras and Tantras of the Fourth Deliverer of this fortunate aeon,
Who possess an abundance of good qualities like a thousand-petalled lotus,
O peerless, great Spiritual Guide, may you live for a very long time.

The holy Dharma, a treasury of jewels that is difficult to find for many aeons,
Is borne forth on the chariot of your excellent, superior intention;
O Protector who destroy the samsaric miseries of vast numbers of disciples,
Great Knowledge Hero arisen from an ocean (of wisdom), may you live for a very long time.

In his foreword to Geshe Kelsang's Buddhism in the Tibetan Tradition, published by Routledge and Kegan Paul in 1984, even the 14th Dalai Lama addressed Geshe Kelsang Gyatso by his correct title.

"Very often people who are interested in studying Tibetan Buddhism are dissuaded from doing so because they cannot always find books that are written in a way that they can easily follow... I am therefore happy that Geshe Kelsang Gyatso has attempted to present the basic teachings of Lord Buddha in a manner that people can relate to and put them into practice in their daily lives. I would like to thank the translator and editors for their efforts." H.H. The Dalai Lama (signed and sealed).

See also the refutation of the smear that Geshe Kelsang Gyatso was expelled from his monastery.

This is taken from the www.newkadampatruth.org site, well worth a visit if you have not already seen it.

thaimonk

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 652
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #8 on: July 25, 2010, 11:35:35 AM »
The certification thing of course is not a big deal.  There are plenty of "certified" geshes nowadays, it's not nearly as rigorous as before in Tibet.  But it is important to recognize that Geshe Kalsang did actually study the classic scriptures and obtained a level of recognition in comprehending them.  So what he is transmitting is built on a solid foundation, because these including very traditional subjects like Chandrakirti's commentary on Nagarjunas' works.  Giving teachings on these subjects without studying in a traditional manner is very problematic as some erroneous views may get begin to be propagated.  I certainly hope every modern day teacher giving teachings on subjects like has actually struggled and relied on a teacher to gain an internal comprehension of the material.

CERTIFICATION DOES NOT MAKE YOU QUALIFIED. BUT GADEN, SERA AND DREPUNG HAVE A SET STUDY AND PROGRAM FOR 600 YEARS. Those who go thru the program are presented this important certificate and gives confidence to many people. It's like getting Phd in Psychology from Harvard as oppose to being treated by someone who has studied Psychology and deems himself fit.
Agains, the example above is not pervasive.

thaimonk

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 652
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #9 on: July 25, 2010, 11:38:26 AM »
It should be obvious that Geshe Kelsang is a Rinpoche!
Geshe Kelsang Gyatso Liberated Mahayanna Buddhism from Dictators by Founding the Kadampa on the Principles on the Bill of Rights!
That makes Him My Hero!


 A Rinpoche? He himself and his whole group are against the whole Rinpoche/tulku thing. Unless you mean Rinpoche as he is precious. If that's the case all sentient beings are Rinpoches also.

triesa

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 609
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #10 on: July 25, 2010, 03:34:01 PM »
Whether Geshe Kelsang is a Geshe or a Rinpoche or not, it really doesn't matter. I would rather look at the results of what he has achieved. All the books that he has written that have touched the lives of many and the Dharma centers he has created around the world that have benefited so many are simply remarkable.

It is like mother Teresa, who is just a simple nun, without any particular title,but look at her work, so many people have benefited from just herself alone. It is incredible. I adore and admire mother Teresa.

I would choose to look at all the good qualitues that Geshe Kelsang has versus judging him on whether his Geshe title is real of fake, have said that, there is no harm of knowing the truth, but that doesn't mean that I would look at him differently, the impact and benefit of his Dharma work speak for itself.

Triesa

Big Uncle

  • Moderator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1995
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #11 on: July 25, 2010, 06:44:23 PM »
Yes, there are no doubt about Geshe Kelsang Gyatso's qualifications after reading some of his amazing books. However, I don't deny that he does have a lot of disgruntled students which is....dare I say it? A little reminiscent of the Dalai Lama with regards to Dorje Shugden. I think this is an important point because all Lamas have that due to samaya and different levels of perception.

Of course, many Shugden practitioners would claim not to be students of the Dalai Lama but if it wasn't for his ban, all of us would be fawning over him and calling him our Guru or the all-omniscient Chenrezig. What an alternate universe that would be....Perhaps, not as many people would have become Shugden practitioners anyway and this website probably wouldn't have existed as well. So strange how a ban can mobilise so much support and attention for this obscure but beneficial Tibetan deity. Well, the Dalai Lama could just renounce the ban but I don't think he is too concerned about his name and fame because if he was, he would do it in a better and a more logical way. Sorry, I digress.

Big Uncle   

honeydakini

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 401
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #12 on: July 25, 2010, 08:09:22 PM »
So strange how a ban can mobilise so much support and attention for this obscure but beneficial Tibetan deity. Well, the Dalai Lama could just renounce the ban but I don't think he is too concerned about his name and fame because if he was, he would do it in a better and a more logical way. Sorry, I digress.

Big Uncle   

This is a good point Big Uncle.

The several claims that the dalai lama is doing this merely for name and gain and power doesn’t really make sense to me – if he really was after that, then wouldn’t it be “easier” to achieve this by just “going along” with what everyone wanted and said was good? This is not just some obscure deity after all, but a practice that just about every Gelugpa practitioner and sangha were doing.

Why, even after all the protests (which doesn’t look very good at all for him), court cases, media coverage, smear campaigns against him, is he still so adamant about this ban? Why not just be the world’s nobel peace winner again and just call a truce with this whole issue?

Helena

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 653
    • Email
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #13 on: July 25, 2010, 08:47:38 PM »
Both Big Uncle & Honeydakini have raised interesting points.

I had not thought about how much damage HHDL is actually doing to his reputation and image by enforcing the ban on DS in the manner that he has done so. In fact, come to think of it, this whole issue is destroying everything that he has achieved over the years. Because now, there are more people questioning where is the Nobel Peace Prize Winner in HHDL? Some people are viewing HHDL as more of a tyrant and dictator because of this issue and this is certainly something that would not be of an advantage, if HHDL is wanting to clamour for more power and popularity.

What's more - the division and dissension are happening both within the Tibetan community and outside of it.

So, the question is WHY would HHDL take on such high risks, full knowing what it will do to him?

This is something we should all contemplate on.

Helena

DSFriend

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 955
Re: Is Geshe Kelsang A Geshe?
« Reply #14 on: July 25, 2010, 09:57:15 PM »
The certification thing of course is not a big deal.  There are plenty of "certified" geshes nowadays, it's not nearly as rigorous as before in Tibet. 

Why would it be not as rigorous? It gives the impression that the great monasteries of Gaden, Sera, and Drepung are not upholding its standards..?