Author Topic: Things are Impermanent in Samsara  (Read 5021 times)


  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1491
Things are Impermanent in Samsara
« on: April 01, 2015, 10:57:19 PM »
I am pleasantly surprised Jean-Jacques Annuad the French director of "Seven Years in Tibet" and Brad Pitt has made a successful come back to China in another film about Tibet.  Their situation with China have taken a successful round-about-turn.  They are no longer in exile from China as China have relaxed their policy on the issue.

Talking about all things impermanent; this is a good example of how things are in samsara.

French director once banished from China along with Brad Pitt for 1997 'Tibet' film makes successful return

BEIJING — In his 1997 film "Seven Years in Tibet," French director Jean-Jacques Annaud didn't mince words about the Chinese Communist Party. The based-on-a-true-story movie, starring Brad Pitt as an Austrian mountaineer who befriends the adolescent Dalai Lama in the years before China's 1950 invasion of the plateau, ended with several blunt title cards:

"One million Tibetans have died as a result of the Chinese occupation of Tibet. Six thousand monasteries were destroyed," read one. Said the next: "In 1959, the Dalai Lama was forced to flee to India. He still lives there today, trying to promote a peaceful resolution with the Chinese. In 1989, he was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize."

The movie so rankled Beijing that not only was the film banned in China but Annaud, Pitt and his costar, David Thewlis, were also declared personae non gratae and unwelcome to enter the country. And to this day, Beijing continues to be extremely touchy about Tibet and the Dalai Lama (whom they regard as a separatist; China even protested President Barack Obama's recent meeting with the exiled spiritual leader).

But somewhat surprisingly, Annaud's Chinese exile has ended. Not only has he been allowed back into the country, but he has made a new film here - a $40-million, 3-D adaptation of the Chinese novel "Wolf Totem" that arrived in mainland theaters just in time for the Chinese New Year holiday. The movie, which has earned $32 million so far, will roll out in France next, and Sony has distribution rights in the United States and a number of other markets.

The story, set during the Cultural Revolution of the 1960s, centers on a young Beijing intellectual's fascination with the wolves he encounters when he's sent to teach Mandarin to minority nomadic herders in the majestic, scenic grasslands of Inner Mongolia.

On one hand, the wildlife drama is a natural for Annaud, who has previously made compelling stars of vicious fauna in his films "The Bear" and the tiger story "Two Brothers."

But the bleak, semi-autobiographical novel by Jiang Rong - a democracy activist who was jailed after the Tiananmen Square massacre - is fraught with potential political tripwires. Unexpectedly approved by censors, the book, published in 2004, became a bestseller. The story, in part, is a denunciation of ecologically disastrous government "modernization" schemes. But like "Seven Years," it is also a critique of majority Han Chinese chauvinism vis-a-vis ethnic minorities.

Unlike in Annaud's Tibet film, the Communist cadres in "Wolf" aren't arrogantly stomping on Buddhist mandalas or mowing down monks with firearms. But when they order the local herdsmen to snatch wolf cubs from their dens and kill them, and foolishly try to introduce farming and industry to the steppe, they hardly come off as benevolent, much less intelligent, leaders.

Annaud said he was as surprised as anyone to be approached by Jiang and a Chinese production team about adapting the book for the big screen.

"I was aware of the novel and had read some excerpts in the French press. But I remember saying to myself, this was something I'd love to do, but of course it's not going to be for me," recalled Annuad, 71, who said the book reminded him of his own sojourn in the 1960s as a young man to Cameroon, where he witnessed misguided and destructive agricultural "development" programs implemented by French agronomists.

Reminding Jiang and his colleagues of China's official reception for "Seven Years," the director said: "Those charming people just smiled and said, well, we have changed, China has changed. ... We don't know how to do what you do. Therefore, we need you." Annaud said he was never asked to apologize for or renounce "Seven Years."

"This is the - should I say - the Oriental politeness: You don't talk about things that may put your partner in an uneasy position," Annaud said. "So, no, we don't talk about it." The director still stands by "Seven Years," adding, diplomatically and carefully, that he sees a common thread between that work and "Wolf Totem."

"I am pleased that I had this positive feeling for this minority of China. I think the beauty of China ... is that it is a country of diverse culture. I think we all have to learn together and respect each other. This is one of the messages of this 'Wolf Totem.' It is respecting people who speak a different language and have different ways of living. It is important for all of us."

Though "Wolf" can certainly be read in a political fashion, it is first and foremost a story of man and nature that required extraordinary preparation and logistical feats starting in 2008. Actual shooting lasted 160 days over a year and a half, from mid-2012 to late 2013.

The production team spent years finding, raising and training a group of wolves in China under the direction of Canada-based trainer Andrew Simpson. Annaud said he and his crew drove nearly 25,000 miles in a four-wheel drive searching for the perfect unspoiled landscapes.

But nature didn't always cooperate. When snow failed to materialize for one epic blizzard scene, the production had to rent 18 large trucks and send them 1,200 miles away to get snow. In the course of filming, the mercury dipped as low as minus-30 degrees, with winds of 50 mph; his cinematographer lost feeling in his feet and has never recovered.

"It was madness," Annaud said.

A meticulously choreographed seven-minute sequence - which sees a pack of wolves attacking an equine herd during a night snowstorm - took six weeks to film using a complex mix of live wolves and horses, puppet animals, drones, cranes, a 500-foot blue screen and CGI.

"It combined all of the most difficult things - shooting with animals, shooting at night, shooting in the blizzard, shooting with two species that hate each other. So that was, on paper, a very complicated scene. Plus we had to make sure that no animal would get in danger," said Annaud, showing off his elaborate storyboards for the sequence. "It's exciting because it requires all the tricks in the book. I love it; it's a challenge."

Post-production movie magic was needed to digitally remove trainers and fences from the shots, but a vast majority of the action is real, enhanced in three dimensions.

"What I wanted was the real interconnection. If you put a pack of wolves and a herd of horses running together, you get intense expressions from the wolves. In their eyes, they are woooo," said Annaud, making the sound of a crazed beast. "Doing it in the computer gives you a cartoonish emotion. The goal for me was 98.5 percent real shots."

Asked whether censors insisted he remove anything from the script or the film, Annaud said authorities raised questions about three scenes - including the killing of the wolf cubs - but that he was allowed to retain them.

The movie is an official Chinese-French co-production, and its backers have high hopes that visual spectacle and the conservation theme will entice audiences beyond the mainland. Annaud says previews in France have been enthusiastic but calls the entire endeavor "a daring experiment."

"I found the book very universal," says Annaud. "It would be great if this story can move people around the world."

Read more here:


  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 316
Re: Things are Impermanent in Samsara
« Reply #1 on: April 02, 2015, 03:42:41 AM »
Thank you Icy for bringing this example to the forum.  Indeed things are impermanent in samsara. And Jean-Jacques Annauds movies are beautiful and meaningful. 

Also Brad Pitt who was banned as well visited China in 2014 with his partner Angelina Jolie.

Dondrup Shugden

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 896
Re: Things are Impermanent in Samsara
« Reply #2 on: April 02, 2015, 05:27:37 AM »
"Reminding Jiang and his colleagues of China's official reception for "Seven Years," the director said: "Those charming people just smiled and said, well, we have changed, China has changed. ... We don't know how to do what you do. Therefore, we need you." Annaud said he was never asked to apologize for or renounce "Seven Years."

The changes in Chinese authority is definitely due to their success in governance and influence in the world.  Success does breed confidence and I am glad that for a country like China, the changes seem positive.

As all phenomena is the result of dependant arising, not only the confidence gained that has made China more open, it is the defined teachings of Buddhism that nothing is permanent due to different things happening all the time.

This new movie is requested by the Chinese authorities and they had the grace to acknowledge that only Annaud can do the job. So any BAN against Annuad visiting China is lifted. This also is a form of graciousness and knowing that their ego cannot be in the way to anchor China's ambition on the world stage.

Can the Dalai Lama be as flexible as the Chinese?  If so than maybe there is a chance for Tibetans in exile to go home.


  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1491
Re: Things are Impermanent in Samsara
« Reply #3 on: April 02, 2015, 07:04:45 AM »
Thank you Dondrup Shugden for your input on China and Annaud.  I totally agree with what you have said.

If China can be flexible I am optimistic that the Dalai Lama can be just as flexible too and Tibetans can return to their homeland.  As it is now, many Tibetans are already going home and if they are particularly Shugden Buddhists, the Chinese welcome them home with open arms.   This is how things are and are constantly changing whether one is prepared to accept it or not and reap the benefits.


  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 142
Re: Things are Impermanent in Samsara
« Reply #4 on: April 02, 2015, 07:53:01 AM »
Thank you Icy who update us on the current situation in China. Events and situation in samsara always change so we must make good use of those changes instead of complaints about the change I guess people very afraid of change but I think when changes arises we need to accept the situation and make it better for us .


  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 196
    • Email
Re: Things are Impermanent in Samsara
« Reply #5 on: April 02, 2015, 10:09:08 AM »
Thank you for sharing on the incredible passion of   Jean-Jacques Annuad 's work on the movie "Wolf Totem". He too is a man of substance holding no grudge against China for banning him in the earlier years. Both parties ie the China government and Annuad has let go of their egos and decided to work harmoniously on a great movie which would have benefited  many viewers around the world to learn more of the nature,culture and stories of China.
Taking on a similar note, China and the Tibetan government should also work towards a harmonious end to their disputes, in order to allow the people to move on with their lives and not hold on to empty promises.
If Tibetan Dorje Shugden practitioners are welcomed to return to China(Tibet land), His Holiness the Dalai Lama and the CTA should also close ranks with DS practitioners and end the controversy and ban on DS  and allow people to practice freely, as they wish. Everything in this world works well only if done in harmony. All parties should let go of their differences and egos and allow people to practice freely. This is the only way that will benefit more people.