dorjeshugden.com
About Dorje Shugden => General Discussion => Topic started by: Mana on December 30, 2010, 08:45:41 AM
-
The Tibetan Govt of Dharamsala are regular visitors to this website. They religiously always check in on the guestbook and our forum here.
This website contains so much information, they cannot resist. Many of the views we write here, later are countered in speeches by them of course not quoting the source, but you can see they are DEFINITELY reading here.
We are the only website that provide all around views for them to tap into. This website without wanting to has become a powerful resource of activities updates for them.
This website is not for political purposes, but strictly spiritual. We wish to bring Dorje Shugden's practice to many who will benefit.
So if you wish to be heard, your thoughts, expressions and ideas to get noted, then be involved on the forum or at least the guestbook. Where else can the Tibetan Govt get information? Only a few limited places. This is one of their haunts. Keep writing!
Mana
-
This makes tremendous sense.
tk
-
I do hope the TGIE come here regularly and see that:
1. Dorje Shugden practitioners are mostly peace-loving and want harmony among ALL.
2. Dorje Shugden practitioners are mostly not anti-Dalai Lama - on the contrary - and please read our MANY discussions on this issue!
3. The Dorje Shugden practitioners who visit this site are mostly not interested in politics and only Dharma.
I say mostly as there are some who disagree but generally, this is the perspective of most who come to this site as far as i have observed.
Anyway, the TGIE only have to read the mission statement of this website and read the many threads of this forum to see where the hearts of many Dorje Shugden practitioners are.
-
Yeah I do really hope they come hear and READ and THINK (if they can) and hopefully with some miracle they may come to realise disharmony is not the key in expanding their mission.
What i truly hope is that from reading all the news and articles here, they'd come to accept that Dorje Shugden will grow to matter what they say, so might as well just accept it although you may not like it.
This is reality, we cannot expect the entire world to just follow one form of Buddhist view - that's why we have so many different schools of Buddhism and that is why we also have so many different spiritual paths and religion on earth.
Ultimately we're all here to spread the Dharma and not politics.
If Ds is really Bad, then why worry, let those who a doing the Bad get their karma...
Karma is the key to everything, so why bother and create more negative karma for oneself by reacting with negative harmful actions. That is to me contradictory to Karma which is the basis of Buddha's teaching. I don't think Buddha said kill, hurt, judge people who don't follow you views is good karma.
-
What i truly hope is that from reading all the news and articles here, they'd come to accept that Dorje Shugden will grow to matter what they say, so might as well just accept it although you may not like it.
This is reality, we cannot expect the entire world to just follow one form of Buddhist view - that's why we have so many different schools of Buddhism and that is why we also have so many different spiritual paths and religion on earth.
Really good thoughts expressed correctly. I agree.
-
I do hope the Tibetan government will visit this website more and more often, i pray that their mind will become clearer after visiting this website (and with the blessing of our Wisdom protector) .
I love this forum as the information are very complete, up to date and not bias. It took me quite some time to decide to write in this forum and I hope other DS practitioner will join in and share theirs experience which will inspire more.
-
I think it is very good that TGIE is visiting this web-site.
I think this web-site has been designed for all to visit, being not-sectarian.
And I truly appreciate the moderator's work here when they insure that the debates in the forum do not fuel an argument, but on the contrary pacify it. That, I think, is most helpful for any truth-seeker visiting the site, and I hope TGIE visitors are truth-seekers indeed.
-
If the TGIE do visit, I wish to say this to them:
Please know that we respect and love the Dalai Lama very much, and this situation is very sad for all of us. Please do not act in such damaging, hurtful ways to Dorje Shugden practitioners. If they wish to practice, can't you just leave them alone and let them practice on their own? All the attacks, violence is not necessary.
By acting so aggressively towards Shugden practitioners, and by denying them any welfare or help from your government, makes you look (very unfortunately) like a very undemocratic, backward government. It reflects very badly upon your own leader the Dalai Lama, who is so compassionate and such a highly respected lama. People will look at what you are doing to your own people and ask, "Does the dalai lama, their leader, permit these kinds of violence and discrimination?" It is sad, but you are causing the destruction of your own leader's reputation.
Please just act with kindness and patience and tolerance towards those that you even disagree with. Even from a purely diplomatic and political point of view, that would be the best way for the reputation and standing of your government. Acting in a 16-century kind of way with witchhunts and discrimination will not earn you any respect on a global level. It is very logical, isn't it?
-
Please just act with kindness and patience and tolerance towards those that you even disagree with. Even from a purely diplomatic and political point of view, that would be the best way for the reputation and standing of your government. Acting in a 16-century kind of way with witchhunts and discrimination will not earn you any respect on a global level. It is very logical, isn't it?
Whatever damage done, we have to let go and move on. All of us have to, whether you are DS practitioners or non-DS practitioners. No matter which school of buddhism you may be from, lets act according to buddha's teachings, be kind and patience to those whom we disagree with. Only at times of disagreement can we truely practise what we are taught.
I like this website because like what Wisdom being said, the majority of forum participants are only interested in spreading Dorje Shugden's practice and not interested in any kind of politics. We are only interested in bringing Dorje Shugden's practice to benefit more beings.
And that is basically what this website is all about.
-
What's funny and illogical is that the TGIE can rely on Nechung, a worldly spirit to help them make crucial state decisions. And we all know some prediction made have been false alarm, yet they can point the finger on Dorje Shugden, saying DS practice is bad and DS a spirit?
If TGIE could seek the help of Nechung a worldly spirit, why not seek the help of DS also to help with Tibet? The more powerful allies the better, no? I mean if high lama's can't get rid of him and those fire puja failed, he must be pretty powerful right? So why not just be friends, better then enemy. Then can have postcards like this one my friend made :)
-
Yes I do feel that CTA is monitoring this forum and this website. That is why we do talk about Tibetan issues because we do care. We care because the Tibetans have brought Buddhism to us so we are concerned about their welfare despite the way that they have treated us, Dorje Shugden practitioners. Because no matter how you want to see it, the more progressive ones in Dharamsala are actually the Dorje Shugden practitioners because they can still hold on to Dorje Shugden despite the ban and some of them like Kundeling Rinpoche can even stand up to the ban. Serkong Tritul started up a Dharma center outside of the CTA and recognized a tulku who is non Tibetan. And that organization is growing very well. NKT was started by Geshe Keslang Gyatso and look at how his organization has grown. FPMT, started by Lama Yeshe is also a Dorje Shugden practitioner. What has non Dorje Shugden practitioners done so far that are also Gelug? Non gelugs who go against Dorje Shugden are not counted because Dorje Shugden is never a part of their lineage.
Now, imagine if all of these lamas, GKG, Lama Osel, Pabongkha Rinpoche, Trijang Rinpoche, Kundeling Rinpoche all combined forces to work for Tibet's independence, somehow or rather CTA will get independence before the 99 year lease is ended. Why talk about uniting Tibet when they cannot even unite with their own people? What unity is there in the ban? If all the DS lamas were working hand in hand with the Dalai Lama and CTA to work towards the independence, they would have gotten it sooner than now. Wake up, CTA.
-
This is so good to know that the Tibetan Government in Dhramsala are visiting this very same forum here like myself. I have learnt so much from this forum and also website. I also like the fact that we can voice our concern and debate with other participants here. Surely the people in the Tibetan Government who visit this forum are very highly intelligent individuals and by now they would have realized that Dorje Shugden is really an enlightened being and not a spirit? Just as triesa, I participate in this forum only for the purpose of learning more about DS and not for any political reason. And I have great respect for HHDL too.
-
One of the more obvious signs that they are visiting us and taking up suggestions from us is this piece of news on Phayul:
Tibetan minister lobbies for support in South Africa
Phayul[Friday, August 24, 2012 03:31]
DHARAMSHALA, August 24: Kalon Dicki Chhoyang, the Tibetan minister for Information and International Relations is currently in South Africa, meeting leaders and speaking on the critical situation inside Tibet.
The minister also met with representatives of different political parties for consultations and briefings on the current human rights situation in Tibet and the ongoing wave of self-immolations, which now numbers 49.
The cabinet member of the Dharamshala based Central Tibetan Administration, on her maiden visit to the African nation, held a joint press conference with the Democratic Alliance, the Congress of the People, and the Inkatha Freedom Party.
In a statement issued by Chhoyang, she called the Tibetan struggle “a people's fight for its right to exist with its own distinct cultural identity and language.”
“This includes the right to practice their religion openly and without hindrance from the State as permitted in all free countries. We are not seeking to secede from China, " Kalon Chhoyang reaffirmed.
With growing bilateral ties between South Africa and China, the Tibetan minister urged South African leaders to uphold their cherished values of human rights protection and democracy in their dealings with China.
“Therefore, the people of Tibet have great expectations that the people of South Africa may exercise moral leadership,” Kalon Chhoyang said.
She also called for greater support for the Tibetan struggle.
“In an age where we seek to resolve conflicts peacefully, the international community must stand behind these principles by supporting movements, such as the Tibetan struggle, which are firmly committed to non-violence and dialogue" states Kalon Chhoyang.
“As Tibetan areas where self-immolations took place have been closed to the international press and community, the Central Tibetan Administration encourages foreign governments and international bodies to pursue efforts to send fact-finding delegations.”
Mangosuthu Buthelezi, Member of Parliament and leader of the IFP, in a commentary said he was pleased to meet the Tibetan minister in Durban.
“I have supported this cause because I believe that the democratisation and decentralisation of China can start from Tibet,” Buthelezi said.
“But I also support Tibet because, despite the continued atrocities and human rights violations perpetrated against them, Tibetans have pursued their decades-long struggle exclusively through the methods of nonviolence, negotiations and moral high ground.”
I have commented before that the CTA sits back and does not make relations with other countries and leaves Dalai Lama to do the job for them. It is really the first time on Phayul that I read that the CTA people are actually going out to lobby for independence somewhere else other than um, China or the Indian government. Which is a very good sign that they are growing. Next, to lift the ban!
-
I am not surprised at all that Tibetan govt often visits this website. Where else can they get the truth? In fact, this is good news. I am sure, among them, there are many who are ignorant of who Dorje Shugden is. They could be just following the herd. But with a forum that is so full of information, and when they understand, I will not be surprised if they are many closet practitioners arising from that!
-
I am not really surprised. They may even have a full time person daily checking all sites and gathering information.
-
Ha ha ha ...I really like what Rihana suggested ! That there are even members of the TGIE that have become closet Dorje Shugden practitoners , after reading or checking out this TRUTH revealing website.
Indeed , this site is THE leading authority for anything and everything Dorje Shugden! Well , to the people behind the scenes for this site , give yourselves a big fat pat on the back for the EXCELLENT work you guys are doing ! Please keep it up.
When your "competitor" or " opponent" ( for the lack of a better word ) checks you out seriously and reacts to the moves you make ...that is flattery at its highest degree ! You guys are DEFINITELY on the right track in bringing this UNJUST ban down. May you guys be well and happy , sadhu to you all.
-
This is indeed flattering to know that this forum has become the voice of those unheard and shun upon by their own people and Government. It is also the voice for true unity and harmony for every one, and isn't compassion about accepting differences and getting along? perhaps practice a little Buddhism in Buddhist claimed Government - maybe pretend if you can't be real?
It would be so right, awesome, politically correct and definitely would gather more support and love if the CTA was smart enough to release an official statement that there is NO BAN or discrimination towards Dorje Shugden practitioners and hence they are entitled equally to the schools, hospitals and welfare facilities just like any other Tibetans on the street. And what's this about an ID card that shows you are either a Dorje Shugden practitioner or not... can we remove that completely as it is totally like being racist and prejudice prejudice! Totally unacceptable. CTA we do hope you are a wise Givt for your people without any creed, race, or religion that is biased, and that you abide in true democracy would be a good start :)
-
I think it is actually very good for them to know that they are people actually speaking up... The practice does not just exist among the Tibetans, it is actually a practice that was well recognized by many from long time ago. Therefore the practice still exist today. It is not like a practice that was just formed yesterday. It is very unlikely for us to go back in time 350 years ago to prove the authenticity of the practice right? What is left is the result of the practice to speak for itself eg the scripture, the recorded facts, the practitioners and of course the countless Lamas who reincarnated that come back life after life to bring the practice to us. So I think it is a very good channel for the CTA to listen to the voice from outside.
It is also vital for them to gather more information regarding this practice. It should not be just be plain ignorant and insists on the ban but to study more regarding its existence and vision. In that order, they can too help their people better and push their culture to a higher level.
-
I am sure they do if they are intelligent.
And it is quite bizzare with CTA. I have heard very old monks in Chatreng who has said, as long as they are Trijang Rinpoche students, they might be seen to be against Shugden but they are fiercely loyal to Trijang Rinpoche. Most of them are serving their duties close to HH and CTA is because of Trijang Rinpoche instructions.
-
This is exciting ! Seriously the CTA people are checking this website and forum frquently ?
Well, dear CTA, say hello to TRUTH and be enlightened (put intended, sorry).. Your ban ain't gonna stick for too long, cos when more and more people knows the true situation and who Dorje Shugden is, you guys are gonna look kind of, err, stupid keeping the ban on for all the wrong reasons !!
Get doses of reality and listen to the voices in this forum and guest book from this website, you will soon see the light !!!
Forget about the ban and start doing something constructive, for once, will you ??
-
Let them be. Welcome the anti shugdens....the more the merrier for us to practice tolerance and patience. Having so much informations on this websites, which includes audio and videos, i wont be surprise if a few or even more anti shugdens evetually see liht and raise doubts about the ban.
-
This is indeed flattering to know that this forum has become the voice of those unheard and shun upon by their own people and Government. It is also the voice for true unity and harmony for every one, and isn't compassion about accepting differences and getting along? perhaps practice a little Buddhism in Buddhist claimed Government - maybe pretend if you can't be real?
CTA is not a Buddhist government. How many Buddhist governments out there that close down temples and confiscate the property of Lamas due to sheer jealousy? CTA is the only one in the world who would this kind of thing. They have been doing it for hundreds of years and even recently they have been using tulkus as a political toy.
It would be so right, awesome, politically correct and definitely would gather more support and love if the CTA was smart enough to release an official statement that there is NO BAN or discrimination towards Dorje Shugden practitioners and hence they are entitled equally to the schools, hospitals and welfare facilities just like any other Tibetans on the street. And what's this about an ID card that shows you are either a Dorje Shugden practitioner or not... can we remove that completely as it is totally like being racist and prejudice prejudice! Totally unacceptable. CTA we do hope you are a wise Givt for your people without any creed, race, or religion that is biased, and that you abide in true democracy would be a good start :)
If that were to happen, China would listen to them immediately. India would respect them as a real government. They would have more unity, the unity that they wanted so much, not like what they are now: just an empty dream that they are pursuing that has no fruit at all. It is hilarious when they claim that they want unity for Tibet, but they discriminate against Dorje Shugden practitioners in their backyard.
Dear CTA,
If you are following our forum, please do learn on the ways of the world and what we have written here. It would help you guys a lot in your quest for Tibetan freedom. Do lift the ban, as it is the best way to work towards Tibet's independence.
-
To the CTA- you a destroying the lineage of the Dalai Lamas, the Gelug lineage. Have no doubt, all that you are doing to protect your own miserable selves at the expense of millions is not forgotten and never in doubt. You are destroying over 350 years of Tibetan wisdom and practice. Lama Tsongkapa would be looking down upon you with horror. Read this and understand fully the folly of what you are doing!
http://www.dorjeshugden.com/forum/index.php?topic=2552.15 (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/forum/index.php?topic=2552.15)
-
The way the ban is happening does not make any sense, on top of that it makes your administration draconian like.
Want to win accolades for fighting the good fight and promoting democracy, banning the Dorje Shugden practice is not one of them. The West has far too long used the Tibetan issue to pressure China, once the West has ceased to have use for Tibet then forget your support from the Western nations.
-
This website is not for political purposes, but strictly spiritual. We wish to bring Dorje Shugden's practice to many who will benefit.
Mana
This is so correct. Many are mixing the Dorje Shugden with politics, and this is all this website is NOT about! I can see many that this website is not about to destroy the CTA or TGIE, but works towards lifting the ban (and stop discrimination towards Dorje Shugden practitioners especially in Tibet community).
Dorje Shugden practitioners should encourage more practitioners to write in this forum and together, we can show CTA (since they are watching) that we really don't care much about the politics but the spreading of Dorje Shugden practices!!
-
It makes sense that the CTA people is visiting this website because, i believe, that many of them are either secret practitioners of Dorje Shugden, or that they want to find out more about this website and the news that it carries. After all, we are the leading website about Dorje Shugden and they could learn a lot just by reading articles from this website. The more they visit, the more that they will understand about Dorje Shugden's true nature and the Dalai Lama's real message and perhaps, they would even lengthen the Dalai Lama's life by acting in accordance with the Dharma.
-
The good news is the Tibetan Government often visits this forum. The bad news is that they are not learning and do something good and democratic.
So sad, may be still hope for the awakening of CTA.
-
The Tibetan government or the CTA may visit this forum often and read all the comments left by others ie. DS practitioners but what do they learn more about?
Do they learn to keep tabs on the "water" to feel what is going on amongst the DS practitioners and device the next strategy? I hope not. It would feel like a 'cat and mouse' game then.
I hope the CTA will learn to reflect on the "disadvantage" of their stand on banning Dorje Shugden practice and decides to lift the ban instead, for the common good for Buddhism.
-
It is WONDERFUL to know that the CTA themselves are frequent visitors to the website.
Even for my own personal use for myself to catch up on the latest developments on the Dorje Shugden ban as well as to get more knowledge on Dorje Shugden, other Buddhas and also general Buddhism topics.
This forum is one huge treasure trove bursting full of knowledge for those who want to learn more about Dorje Shugden and the controversy.
The posts on this forum is really irresistible even to someone like me and it's just amazing to know that even the people behind all the controversy can't resist the juicy news available here!
Thank you Mana for sharing this to all of us!
-
Well put, beggar. You have encompassed most if not all the feelings and thoughts of most Shugden practitioners in your comments. Thank you.
-
I believe the Tibetan government has shown concern and at the same worried by the growth rate of the DS practitioners around the world or whether it would eventually affect the CTA status politically. Further, with the existence of this powerful and informative website, the CTA is also curious to know the news and issues which has been discussed and debated and all the activities conducted . Further, they might also send spies to create chaos in the site. When will the CTA wake up ?
-
Has CTA learned from the lessons?
Does CTA even think these are lessons or just criticism that they have to defend against and shut it out?
I agreed with what have been said by other posters, being in political position CTA can do so much more from Tibetan's current predicament. Is this happening now?
-
Seriously judging from results, CTA is only gathering all the spiritual information and act against Shugdenpas. Using information to twist and turn it into slander and denials.
If there was any assistance to know that Shugden devotees are peaceful and only ask for the right to our faith, things would have changed.
Persecution is being executed at newer and higher levels. It is such a same to develop chaos in the Buddhist communities.
-
It is quite surprising that the CTA would want to come and look here. They definitely can see that we post a lot of things about DS and sometimes we do put them down a bit, so why visit this site? The answer is is simple we have a lot of information about Dorje Shugden and other not really related things. This is a sign that the CTA is somewhat trying to learn any info they don't know and probably cricticize it. On the bright side, it shows that all the information here is accurate and reliable, which will prompt more people to come here to look at post.